Call Them Concentration Camps

I’m partaking in an example of supreme 21st century decadence and reading an ebook on my cellphone while walking around on a mossy grassy lawn barefoot. The book is Escape From Camp 14, only the third book I’ve read about North Korea but, like the rest (The Cleanest Race and The Aquariums Of Pyongyang), nearly impossible to put down, except when there is blogging to be done.

This is a brand new book, completely up-to-date, and all about a man who was born into a North Korean concentration camp—usually but not always referred to as gulag or prison in English, the North Koreans call them Kwaliso, or what I think translates to Management Stations—and who somehow managed to escape.

Although these Management Stations are not gassing people by the millions, as the Nazis were, plenty of people are still dying there, and while the resemblance of these places may indeed by closer to Soviet gulags, there is still a certain charm to that Russian word—since Russia is the land of gorgeous onion domes stacked on top of one another like wedding cakes, vodka in the cold winters, beautiful women, charming accents, intellectuals, brilliant writers and composers, the only military that poses even a remote threat to America’s, and wailing choral music that must be played on a movie’s soundtrack whenever that movie’s characters visit Moscow. They never go to St. Petersburg, because most Americans probably wouldn’t recognize the frozen canals. It’s not to say that gulags weren’t awful, but there’s a lot of positive cultural baggage riding behind Russian words that have entered into the English language. Even though they were our worst enemies for decades, we still beat them, and as with Japan, Germany, and even Vietnam, Americans are usually quite fond of the nations they have defeated in the contest for world domination, so long as they know their place.

Prison is too generic, but concentration camp is pure evil, and I wish more news sources would use this term when describing North Korea, as this kind of rhetoric might help to galvanize a movement to free that nation’s people. As the author of this book writes, people today debate why FDR never bombed the railroads leading to Hitler’s concentration camps, and in the future, after North Korea falls, if North Korea ever falls, people will wonder why we never did anything about it (though the answer is obvious: they have no oil, and the cost to the world economy (a flattened Seoul) would probably be felt for decades).

Anyway, I was walking around outside in this peaceful beautiful place I used to live in, and a part came up in the book (which is inevitable in any book, practically any mention, of North Korea), where the author speculates about when the government is going to fall (like the rapture, it could happen five minutes from now), and I briefly felt a faint surge of fear, because life for me would probably become far more interesting than it already is if that were to occur, to say the least, but then I looked up at the windy sunlit trees and remembered that I was in America, on the other side of the planet, in a town where it’s not completely necessary to lock your doors, and then another inevitable event occurred: I began to think of not going back.

The last time I seriously considered doing so was in Chiang Mai, some time ago; the only thing that stopped me was the fact that I had left my computer in my apartment in Busan. This time I brought my computer with me.


Comments

Re: Call Them Concentration Camps

Nice try at your writing, but I disagree on a fair couple of points.

You mention that Russia has "the only military that poses even a remote threat to America’s." Hmmm, maybe you haven't done your homework on China?

You also mention that "[...] as with Japan, Germany, and even Vietnam, Americans are usually quite fond of the nations they have defeated in the contest for world domination, so long as they know their place." Maybe you haven't done your homework here again, but (North) Vietnam kind of won the war, not the Americans. And last time I checked, Americans are still not really fond of Russia and its semi-autocratic, multibillioniaire head of state, Putin. Oh, wait, maybe you didn't know the Russians usually veto against the West at the U.N. 

You also seem to idealistically believe that meddling into someone else's business (in this case, into North Korea's sovereignty) is only a money matter. International politics is slightly more complicated. Who has the right to enter North Korea and start a war with its million strong military? Who will pay the cost? Would you like your brother or sister to risk his/her life to maybe end up saving the life of a North Korean prisoner? And what are going to be the strings attached to this act of "benevolence"? Quasi-colonialism?

Lastly, you idealize a small town in America where it's "not necessary to lock your doors." Well, I'm happy for you if you live in the middle of Arkansas or Eastern Oregon, but usually locking your doors is not exactly a sign that you live in a failed state. I should also add that many in Korea do not lock their doors. In fact, they don't even need to think about turning in a key, because most of them have automatic locks anyway. But for those living in the countryside, the same rules probably apply for where you are living. As far as I'm concerned, I feel much safer living in Korea than in the US, where people have gun, where income gap is widening exponentially, and where the corrupt political system is already causing the downfall of what is still the richest nation on earth.

I also find rather amusing that you seem to portray yourself as a person who will not come back to Korea because it is "dangerous" or "unstable" due to the "imminent collapse" of North Korea (which, by the way, every "expert" in the early 1990s predicted it would happen in just a few years). North Korea is, as it turns out, one of the most stable country on the planet. Not the best place to be, to be sure. But North Korea in itself will never factor in any of my decisions to live or not to live in South Korea...